Minu

Minu › Guide

Is screen addiction real? Signs to watch for and what the science says

Artovia Labs · · 8 min read

"She's addicted to her phone." You can hear it at almost any school pickup. But look at the official lists of medical diagnoses and you'll find something surprising: "screen addiction" isn't on them. The World Health Organization's list includes just one screen-related disorder, and it's about gaming [1].

Does that mean you don't need to worry if your child can't put the phone down? No. But it changes what you should look for. Let's find out together where the line falls between screen addiction and simply loving something a lot.

Where's the line between addiction and loving something a lot?

In 2019 the World Health Organization added "gaming disorder" to the new edition of its disease classification, ICD-11, which took effect on January 1, 2022 [1]. Read the criteria closely and you'll find the answer to the question parents ask most: there's no number of hours in them.

Instead, they look for three signs [1]:

This pattern has to cause significant problems in school, family or social life, and it usually needs to last at least 12 months. If symptoms are severe, a shorter period can be enough [1].

Picture two children. One plays two hours of games every evening but still does homework, sees friends and goes to bed on time. That child doesn't fit the pattern. Another plays one hour a day but has been neglecting school, friends and sleep because of it for months. Even with less time on screens, that child deserves a closer look.

So what about hours of videos on a phone, or social media? Is there a diagnosis for those?

What about phones and social media?

No. The other major psychiatric manual, the DSM-5, added only "internet gaming disorder" in 2013, and only as a condition needing further research [2]. There's no official diagnosis for smartphone or social media addiction.

But no diagnosis doesn't mean no problem. Researchers use the term "problematic smartphone use": use that disrupts daily life and is hard to stop. A review combining 41 studies of 41,871 children and young people found it in about 1 in 4 of them on average [4]. Problematic use was more common alongside depression, anxiety and poor sleep. That's an association; it doesn't show which causes which.

Which raises an obvious question: is it 1 in 4, or 3 in 100? There's a reason the numbers are so different.

How common is it, and why do the numbers vary so much?

You'll see headlines claiming half of teens are addicted, and experts saying that's overblown. A review that pooled 53 studies covering more than 226,000 people in 17 countries helps explain the gap [3].

It found gaming disorder in about 3% of participants worldwide. When the analysis was limited to studies with stricter methods, the ones that better represent the population, the figure dropped to about 2% [3]. The biggest factor driving the numbers was the measurement itself: which questionnaire and which cutoff a study used. Rates were higher among teens, and about 2.5 times higher in boys than in girls [3].

So "1 in 4" and "3 in 100" don't contradict each other. The first describes a broad pattern of use that makes daily life harder; the second describes a narrow condition that meets diagnostic criteria. What most families face is closer to the first. The good news is that there's a lot you can do about it at home.

What can you do at home?

  1. Protect sleep first. Make the hour before bed screen-free and charge devices outside the bedroom at night [5]. Sleep is one of the things most often disrupted alongside problematic use [4].
  2. Set rules ahead of time, not in the middle of a meltdown. The AAP recommends that families write their media rules together and apply them consistently [6]. When "when, how long and where" are settled in advance, you don't have to argue about them every evening.
  1. Plan what replaces the screen. The AAP's test is that screens shouldn't take the place of sleep, physical activity and family time [6]. Decide together what fills the time instead: a sport, meeting a friend, or a job you do together around the house. We look at which skills chores go along with in children in our guide to screen time by age.
  2. Look at your own habits. The AAP encourages parents to model healthy screen use [5, 6]. No phones at the dinner table can be a rule for everyone.
  3. Talk without blaming. Ask your child what draws them to the game or the videos. It's also the easiest way to understand how serious things are.

The moment these rules are tested most is the moment the screen goes off.

Why is turning the screen off so hard?

A US study of families with children aged 1 to 5 looked closely at that moment: researchers interviewed 27 parents, and 28 more families kept a diary for two weeks [7].

The first finding is reassuring: when screen time ended, children reacted neutrally 59% of the time and positively 19% of the time; 22% of reactions were negative [7]. The second is surprising. Advance warnings like "two more minutes" didn't make the transition easier. They made it harder: children who got a warning were more upset when the screen went away [7].

The easy transitions had things in common. They went better when ending screen time was part of a daily routine, or when a game or video came to a natural end. Transitions ended by technology rather than by a parent (a battery running out, for example) went more smoothly [7].

The study looked at young children; it didn't measure how warnings affect school-age kids. Still, the findings suggest three things for home. Keep the end time the same every day. End at the end of an episode or a game when you can. And let a rule set in advance decide when it's over, not a decision made in the moment.

So what if things still aren't improving after months?

When should you get help?

If the following happen together and have lasted for months, talk to your pediatrician or a child and adolescent mental health professional [1]:

These are the WHO's diagnostic criteria put into everyday language. Only a professional can make a diagnosis.

Questions parents often ask

My child gets angry when the game ends. Is that addiction?

Not on its own. The criteria look for a pattern that lasts months and disrupts life, not a single reaction [1]. If ending screen time is hard every day, agreeing in advance on when it will end, and keeping that the same every day, fits the AAP's advice on consistent limits [6]. In the study of young children, transitions that were part of a routine also went more smoothly [7].

Is there a difference between boys and girls?

Gaming disorder is about 2.5 times more common in boys than in girls [3]. But that gap was measured for gaming only. The same can't be said for problematic phone or social media use; there, looking at the signs is a better guide than looking at gender.

The bottom line

"Screen addiction" is a common phrase, but the condition medicine recognizes is narrower: months of lost control and use that disrupts life. What most families deal with is more common and fixable at home. And its most important piece is often overlooked: sleep.

We explain how screens affect sleep, and why phones shouldn't even stay in the bedroom at night, in our guide to screens and sleep.

Sources

  1. World Health Organization. ICD-11, 6C51 Gaming disorder, and Q&A page. who.int
  2. American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), Section III: Internet Gaming Disorder.
  3. Stevens M. W. R. et al. (2021). Global prevalence of gaming disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 55(6). PubMed
  4. Sohn S. Y. et al. (2019). Prevalence of problematic smartphone usage and associated mental health outcomes amongst children and young people. BMC Psychiatry, 19. doi:10.1186/s12888-019-2350-x
  5. AAP Council on Communications and Media (2016). Media and Young Minds. Pediatrics, 138(5), e20162591. doi:10.1542/peds.2016-2591
  6. AAP Council on Communications and Media (2016). Media Use in School-Aged Children and Adolescents. Pediatrics, 138(5), e20162592. doi:10.1542/peds.2016-2592
  7. Hiniker A., Suh H., Cao S., Kientz J. A. (2016). Screen Time Tantrums: How Families Manage Screen Media Experiences for Toddlers and Preschoolers. Proceedings of CHI 2016, 648–660. washington.edu

This article is for general information and isn't medical advice. If you're concerned about your child's health, talk to your pediatrician. Written by Artovia Labs, the maker of Minu, based on the published sources listed above.